How can I make payments?

  • Online — Log in to our online customer service site to pay online.
  • Phone — Call us to make a payment by phone -  1-800-876-5581
  • Automatic Payments — Set up an installment plan to automatically deduct your payment each month.
  • Mail — Send a check with your monthly bill in the mail.

You can pay for your Progressive policy through the following means:

  • Credit Card
  • PayPal
  • Online Check
  • Personal check or money order
  • Electronic Funds Transfer from your checking account

Money Order/Cashier's Check payments:

Progressive Insurance 
Attn: Cash Processing 
P.O. Box 94561 
Cleveland, OH 44101-4561

Payments without coupon or Online Bill Pay Service:

Progressive Insurance 
DEPT 0561 
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0561